BSME Editors’ Editor 2023 shortlist
We are pleased to announce the shortlist of the Editors' Editor 2023 category. The winner will be voted for by BSME members and entrants to the BSME Awards 2023. If you are a member or an entrant, you will soon receive an email with a link to the voting page. If you would like to become a BSME member, please see our membership page.
The shortlist for the 2023 Editors' Editor is (nominees appear in alphabetical order by surname):
Charlie Baker
Joanna Cummings
Nicola Jeal
Deborah Joseph
Kate Oppenheim
Gideon Spanier
John. L. Walters
Charlie Baker
The Fence
I am delighted, and a little shocked, to be nominated for this award. But I am pleased with the work that The Fence has done these last twelve months, and this feels like a breakthrough year for a project that started in 2019.
From a journalistic standpoint, a highlight has been publishing Mark Blacklock’s investigation into a multi-millionaire paedophile who bought a private school and moved into his own home, a piece that has since been picked up nearly all the major broadsheets – there is, sadly, much more to be told about this story. In Issue 16, we led with a dispatch from Ukraine, where our anonymous correspondent detailed how the country’s LGBT community have continued to hook up even as the bombs fall.
We are a very small team: it is just me working full-time, on a very small annual budget, so to publish longform features of such ambition at such a low cost is something that makes me very proud.
I am very lucky to work with an extraordinarily capable team of editors on a part-time basis: Kieran Morris, Róisín Lanigan, Séamas O’Reilly and Fergus Butler-Gallie. Together, we have helped develop a distinctive tone for the publication, one that is informed, wry yet approachable. I know that many editors and agents look to The Fence to spot the stars of tomorrow – Harriet Rix’s skewering of Guy Shrubsole’s book led to a significant and well-deserved book deal for her.
As a print-first publication, we publish a beautiful magazine every quarter, as Graydon Carter generously describing our publication as ‘the illegitimate offspring of Private Eye and Evelyn Waugh – with a bloodline that stretches back to Gillray and Rowlandson’, yet this year I have also helped expand our digital offering, which has brought in new readers in what is a fiercely competitive marketplace.
Current affairs publications are often bogged down by covering the ‘culture wars’, and I am really happy that we have managed to attract dedicated subscribers from both sides of the political aisle, and provide content that appeals to readers of all ages, while continuing to champion younger voices.
Joanna Cummings
The Grub Street Journal
On April 1st, 2023, I launched The Grub Street Journal – ‘a magazine for magazine people’ – with Media Voices’ Peter Houston.
Our aim? To tackle the biggest questions in magazine publishing… by talking to the people they matter to most. Yes, we are a B2B publication, but one with a difference: brutally honest, yet relentlessly optimistic, we give a voice to editors (and sales people, designers, distributors, and more) encouraging them to think beyond SEO strategies or audience engagement metrics and discuss their concerns, challenges and hopes.
Our first cover feature asked, “What kind of idiots still make magazines?” Of course our first answer was, “us”. But by talking honestly to people in all areas of the industry, we gave them permission to admit it’s tough sometimes. Hell, our third issue has a feature on magazine people’s tattoos – can you get more up close and personal than that?
We are only three issues in, but already we’ve spoken to a fantastic array of people working in this industry; from Glamour’s Deborah Joseph to Time’s Edward Felsenthal, from Creative Director Fiona Hayes to The Atlantic’s Jemima Villaneuva. But Grub Street isn’t just about the ‘big’ names. We’re speaking to magazine people from publications of all sizes – after all, the issues affecting the industry affect us all.
As for why I should win this award… I may not have the cachet of the aforementioned (and brilliant) Deborah Joseph, or the longevity of the impressive John L. Walters. Perhaps I could even be considered foolhardy for attempting to publish a print publication at such a tough time in our unpredictable market. But as someone who has worked in the industry for ten years, I am – I hope – creating a magazine that magazine people want to read, one that both speaks to and reflects the talented magazine community.
One magazine editor said to me recently: “Grub Street makes me feel less lonely”. To me, that means everything. And it’s a huge delight to be shortlisted for this award; with The Grub Street Journal I’m aspiring to quite literally be ‘an editor’s editor’.
Nicola Jeal
The Times Magazine
Nicola Jeal has made the Times magazine a must-read. She has made it famous for agenda-setting features, empathetic personal stories, probing celebrity interviews and meticulously researched profiles that often shed new light on the social issues of the day. But above all it is entertaining and fun, warm and celebratory, high- and lowbrow, packed with surprises and stunning photography. In print it aims to be a perfectly-formed package each week, online it enhances the Times brand and subscriber experience with daily, great long reads. The magazine is now a digital first, as well as print, with content across the week, many stories appearing on the homepage and proving some of the most-read articles of the week, and often of the month. Nicola aims to commission stories that will result in countless news stories picked up by the main news outlets in UK and abroad and trend on Apple news. She always has her finger on the zeitgeist, focussing on growing the digital audience for long-form magazine content.
The big interviews are the most-talked, whether it is cyclist Bradley Wiggins opening up about his sexual abuse; Greta Thunberg admitting to Caitlin Moran that she has to live like a monk so she can never be accused of double standards; or the ‘Bride of Wildenstein, socialite Jocelyn, who has not been seen or heard for 25 years, talking about her life after being vilified.
Nicola strives to produce a magazine with the glossy feel of a monthly married with the news-reactive content of a daily. It is that winning combination that sets it apart.
Deborah Joseph
GLAMOUR, UK
2022/23 has been my most successful and high profile year as editor since I took over at GLAMOUR, almost six years ago. I’m incredibly proud of the work I and my small, but mighty team, have achieved in the past 12 months.
From bringing back the star-studded GLAMOUR Women of the Year Awards (WOTY) last November, after a five-year hiatus, to creating one of the most talked-about and memorable magazine covers in recent history, pregnant transgender man, Logan Brown, in celebration of Pride Month this June.
When it came to WOTY, the challenge was how to bring back a much-loved, influential and lauded event with a fresh twist for our new digital era. We also wanted the GLAMOUR values of diversity, inclusion and activism that I have fostered since taking over, to be at the very heart of the ceremony. From Kim Cattrall to Munroe Bergdorf and Cynthia Erivo to Chirithra Chandran and Soma Sara, the powerful messaging in the room, and on social media, reverberated far and wide. The event also made more profit than any WOTY in its 21 year history, with headline partners, Samsung, Peroni and Uoma Beauty.
Since moving away from being a monthly print magazine, I have revolutionised GLAMOUR into an online-only brand for a Millennial and Gen Z audience, offering them daily news, entertainment and lifestyle content across multiple platforms and always through a female empowerment lens. This year, we have repeatedly set the news agenda, not only with our brave and important Logan Brown cover, showcasing the allyship between women and trans men over reproductive health, but also with viral pieces like GLAMOUR’s Assistant Editor, Emily Maddick’s expose on the sexism and toxicity at her former workplace ITV’s This Morning, when the Phillip Schofield scandal was dominating the news. In January this year, we were the first mainstream magazine brand to showcase three women with disabilities, two in wheelchairs, for our annual Self-Love issue.
I lead my team to always keep GLAMOUR’s finger-on-the-pulse, intentionally capturing the zeitgeist for our socially-conscious readers. The brand’s diversity is also reflected internally across my hiring. It’s incredibly important to me that GLAMOUR has a fully diverse range of voices within the team - leading to plenty of heated, multi generational viewpoints and discussions….which in turn creates brilliant and thought-provoking journalism. My core team have been with me every stage of this six-year journey.
Our aim is always to bring our audience the latest news, opinions and fresh perspectives that challenge our readers’ thinking. My strategy has succeeded in that Glamour’s online growth has exceeded 50 percent since I took over to over 5 million unique readers per month, on the website alone. Glamour UK’s success led me to being appointed European Editorial Director in January 2022 by Anna Wintour, with the remit to replicate the same successes across German and Spanish GLAMOUR. I lead those teams alongside my UK role, helping them pivot successfully to digital-first, also.
On a personal level, I have worked hard to raise GLAMOUR’s profile through my own work, both as BSME Chair, and by writing regularly for national newspapers about key feminist issues that reflect GLAMOUR core values. I’ve written for the Times and the Daily Mail on the reality of women’s lives and remain passionate about championing women and our fight for equality in every aspect of my professional and personal life - it’s something I care deeply about and am therefore privileged to edit GLAMOUR.
Kate Oppenheim
BII News
I was blown away to have been nominated for this award. To be the editor of the BII News magazine is a pleasure and an honour. Everyone involved is passionate about creating a top class magazine that is a must read for our industry. From the articles to the brilliant design, most ably directed and executed by Basia Paczesna-Vercueil, BII News magazine serves its business audience of hospitality professionals extremely well.
Having been an editor of weeklies and even a daily publication in the past, working on a quarterly is not without its challenges – not least in ensuring that the content remains topical, fresh and relevant for our target audience. Part of our success is in the fact that we understand and have empathy with our readership. I’ve edited magazines in the hospitality and retail sectors for more than 30 years, and industry experts and professionals are happy to be interviewed for articles, sharing their insight and forecasts almost on an exclusive basis. And we have no shortage of ideas, thanks to our upbeat and dynamic production meetings, with plenty of input from the amazingly pro-active BII team, under the leadership of Steve Alton and Molly Davis.
In this digital age, I feel immensely privileged to be editing a print magazine.
I am a huge advocate for print, especially in the business-to-business sector and hospitality industry, where operators tend to be out and about, or customer facing, therefore emails and digital content too quickly disappear down into the bowels of the mail box, to remain forever unread.
BII News looks good and feels great. It’s a magazine that makes you want to pick it up and read it. The weight and quality of paper is something we regularly review, under the guidance of Lee Doney, our account manager at our printers, Deltor. Deltor really knows how to look after its clients, being pro-active in notifying us of any impending price hikes, while offering solutions at every turn.
Our magazine is produced by an enthusiastic and extremely capable team, and should I win this award, it is because of them.
Gideon Spanier
Campaign, PodPod
I wanted to be an editor since I was a schoolboy when I drew my own newspaper front pages. Now I have a dream job as I oversee two titles and work with the brilliant teams who produce them.
I believe our journalists should love what they do, but publishing trusted, original journalism is a serious business, which has become more important in the age of artificial intelligence and unreliable online content.
I am proud Campaign and PodPod grew in different ways in the last year. My main focus was advertising title Campaign where I have been editor-in-chief since 2020.
We kept up our record for breaking scoops such as John Lewis’ split from ad agency Adam & Eve/DDB and produced more in-depth tentpole features such as the data-rich agency School Reports.
We also innovated. I devised a sold-out generative AI summit that attracted 200 paying guests and I hosted a daily podcast from the Cannes Lions festival, which drove record monthly downloads. I believe an editorial leader should have a “voice” to support their brand.
Crucially, Campaign’s two-tier subscription strategy paid off as digital subs revenue rose 33% in the judging period — record growth that allowed us to go fully digital and drop print after 55 years this autumn.
I took on an additional role as editorial director of PodPod, an audio-first brand about the craft and business of podcasting, which we launched in October 2022. It has been fantastic to create a new brand, with a weekly podcast and daily news website, and attract big-name guests such as My Dad Wrote A Porno with our “cover star” approach.
It is an honour to be nominated for this award. Everything has been achieved through teamwork and special credit goes to Maisie McCabe, editor of Campaign, and Adam Shepherd, editor of PodPod.
Looking ahead, we must do more to build an inclusive industry, which is why Campaign is partnering with Media For All on new diversity awards. I am excited about the future of magazine media because I see so many opportunities for story-telling and growth in a digital world.
John L. Walters
Eye
Although I’ve been editing a magazine for almost a quarter of a century, I still feel as if I’m new to the job, trying to get my head around it all. There are always so many new things to learn, and I came late to journalism, so I’m still catching up with my peers, whose origin stories go back generations.
I spent the first part of my adult life as a musician, arranger and record producer. A decade went by before I re-invented myself, helped by my journalist wife Clare, and many generous editors and designers.
Along the way I launched a CD journal called Unknown Public (with Laurence Aston) and I wrote music columns for the Independent and the Guardian and subbed extensively on newspapers and magazines. I wrestled with early computers (in music, publishing and design) and websites and social media without losing my love for print. After several years editing Eye, when it was part of some bigger media groups I got the opportunity (in 2008) to do a management buy-out from Haymarket, along with art director Simon Esterson. So Eye has been owned by us – the people who make it – for the past fifteen years, and that’s been a great time to be an indie magazine.
Eye magazine depends upon a tiny team, a substantial network of contributors, loyal advertisers, distributors, magazine shops and committed subscribers and readers. Somehow, they all seem to understand what we’re doing. Eye serves and observes and responds to the design community, which is where we feel most at home. That’s why editing Eye magazine is a great job. The subject matter – including graphic design, photography, illustration, typography and visual culture – are constantly evolving subjects, and the process of putting Eye together is a privilege and a delight.
Disclaimer: The views stated on the statements above are those of the individuals and not the BSME.